Skip to content
SuperMoney logo
SuperMoney logo

Cost of Savings Index (COSI): Definition, Application, and Examples

Last updated 03/26/2024 by

Silas Bamigbola

Edited by

Fact checked by

Summary:
The Cost of Savings Index (COSI) is a financial benchmark used to determine interest rates on adjustable-rate mortgages (ARMs), primarily managed and published monthly by Wells Fargo. It reflects the interest rates paid on certificates of deposit (CDs) by Wells Fargo Bank, providing stability compared to other volatile indexes like LIBOR. COSI plays a crucial role in determining the interest rates borrowers pay on their mortgages, offering both advantages and potential risks.

Compare Home Loans

Compare rates from multiple vetted lenders. Discover your lowest eligible rate.
Compare Rates

Understanding the cost of savings index (COSI)

The Cost of Savings Index (COSI) is a fundamental benchmark used in the realm of adjustable-rate mortgages (ARMs), providing insight into how interest rates are determined for borrowers.Unlike fixed-rate mortgages, where the interest rate remains constant throughout the loan term, ARMs are subject to periodic adjustments based on specified indexes like COSI. As a benchmark, COSI reflects the interest rates paid on certificates of deposit (CDs) by Wells Fargo Bank, serving as a reliable indicator for mortgage lenders and borrowers alike.
One of the defining features of COSI is its stability compared to other volatile indexes like LIBOR. This stability stems from the fact that COSI is based on the interest rates paid on certificates of deposit (CDs), which tend to change more gradually than other market-driven indexes.
Beyond its role as a benchmark, understanding COSI involves delving into its historical context, evolution, and significance within the mortgage market. From its origins with World Savings Bank to its current management and publication by Wells Fargo, the journey of COSI underscores its importance in providing stability amidst economic fluctuations.
Moreover, comprehending COSI entails analyzing its impact on borrowers’ financial decisions and mortgage terms. By understanding how COSI influences adjustable-rate mortgages, borrowers can make informed choices regarding their mortgage options, risk tolerance, and long-term financial goals.
For borrowers, understanding COSI involves recognizing its impact on their mortgage payments. When COSI rates rise, borrowers with COSI-indexed ARMs may experience an increase in their monthly mortgage payments, while a decline in COSI rates could lead to lower payments.
Furthermore, the historical trends of COSI provide valuable insights into its behavior over time. By analyzing past fluctuations and economic conditions, borrowers can gain a better understanding of potential future changes in COSI rates and plan accordingly.

History and evolution of COSI

The history and evolution of the Cost of Savings Index (COSI) trace back to its origins with World Savings Bank, a subsidiary of Golden West Financial Corp. Initially known as the GDW COSI or World Savings COSI, it underwent changes through acquisitions by Wachovia Corp and eventually became the Wells Fargo Cost of Savings Index or Wells COSI. Despite ownership shifts, the fundamental methodology of COSI remained consistent, focusing on CD interest rates.
Over the years, COSI has maintained its reputation as one of the most stable ARM indexes in the industry, offering borrowers a reliable benchmark for their adjustable-rate mortgages. Its stability compared to other volatile benchmarks like LIBOR has made it a preferred choice for lenders and borrowers seeking predictability in interest rate adjustments.
Despite its stability, COSI has experienced fluctuations in response to economic changes and monetary policy shifts. Monitoring these trends and understanding the historical context of COSI can provide valuable insights for borrowers navigating the complexities of the mortgage market.

Pros and cons of COSI-indexed mortgages

Weigh the risks and benefits
Here is a list of the benefits and drawbacks to consider.
Pros
  • Stable index compared to other benchmarks
  • Lower initial rates compared to fixed-rate mortgages
  • Many COSI-indexed ARMs offer payment change caps and lifetime interest rate caps
Cons
  • Long-term interest rate adjustments may exceed fixed-rate mortgages
  • Less advantageous during falling interest rate environments
  • Some mortgages may lack periodic interest rate caps, leading to negative amortization

Wells COSI rates and trends

The Wells Fargo Cost of Savings Index (COSI) serves as a key indicator for borrowers and lenders alike, reflecting fluctuations in CD interest rates. Since its inception in November 2009, when it stood at 2.4%, the Wells COSI has experienced dynamic trends, influenced by various economic factors and monetary policy changes.
Monitoring Wells COSI rates and trends is essential for borrowers considering or currently holding COSI-indexed mortgages. By staying informed about monthly fluctuations and historical patterns, borrowers can anticipate potential changes in their mortgage payments and make proactive financial decisions.
While the Wells COSI offers stability compared to other volatile benchmarks, borrowers should remain vigilant to shifts in market conditions and monetary policy that may impact COSI rates. Understanding the historical context and factors influencing COSI trends can provide borrowers with valuable insights for navigating the complexities of the mortgage market and optimizing their financial strategies.

Comparison with Other ARM index rates

Comparing the Cost of Savings Index (COSI) with other ARM index rates offers borrowers valuable insights into their mortgage options and potential risks. While COSI provides stability, other indexes such as the London Interbank Offered Rate (LIBOR), Monthly Treasury Average (MTA) Index, and the Federal Reserve (Fed) prime rate may exhibit greater volatility, impacting borrowing costs differently over time.
COSI’s stability compared to more volatile benchmarks can be advantageous for borrowers seeking predictability in their monthly mortgage payments, especially during periods of steady or rising interest rates. However, borrowers should also consider factors such as long-term interest rate adjustments, presence or absence of interest rate caps, and historical trends when evaluating the suitability of COSI-indexed mortgages.
Understanding the differences between COSI and other ARM index rates empowers borrowers to make informed decisions tailored to their financial goals, risk tolerance, and market expectations. By analyzing the pros and cons of each index and considering their individual circumstances, borrowers can select the mortgage option that best aligns with their needs and preferences.

Conclusion

The cost of savings index (COSI) provides borrowers with a stable benchmark for adjustable-rate mortgages, offering initial flexibility and payment options. However, borrowers must weigh the advantages of lower initial rates against potential risks of long-term interest rate adjustments and negative amortization. Monitoring COSI trends and understanding mortgage terms is crucial for informed decision-making in a dynamic market.

Frequently asked questions

How does the Cost of Savings Index (COSI) impact adjustable-rate mortgages (ARMs)?

The COSI serves as a benchmark for determining interest rates on ARMs, influencing the monthly payments borrowers make.

Is the COSI index stable compared to other benchmarks?

Yes, the COSI tends to be more stable, providing borrowers with predictability in monthly payments.

What are some potential risks associated with COSI-indexed mortgages?

Long-term interest rate adjustments exceeding fixed-rate mortgages and negative amortization due to the absence of periodic interest rate caps are potential risks.

How are interest rates calculated for ARMs using the COSI index?

In ARMs, the fully indexed interest rate combines the COSI index rate with a fixed margin rate, with additional caps to limit rate increases.

What factors should borrowers consider when evaluating COSI-indexed mortgages?

Borrowers should consider the stability of COSI, potential long-term adjustments, and the presence of interest rate caps.

Are there alternatives to COSI for determining ARM interest rates?

Yes, other common ARM indexes include LIBOR, Monthly Treasury Average (MTA) Index, and the Federal Reserve (Fed) prime rate.

How can borrowers monitor COSI trends to make informed mortgage decisions?

Borrowers can stay informed about COSI trends by regularly reviewing updates provided by Wells Fargo and financial news sources.

Key takeaways

  • COSI serves as a stable benchmark for adjustable-rate mortgages (ARMs)
  • Offers lower initial rates but may lead to higher long-term adjustments
  • Borrowers should understand mortgage terms and monitor COSI trends for informed decisions

SuperMoney may receive compensation from some or all of the companies featured, and the order of results are influenced by advertising bids, with exception for mortgage and home lending related products. Learn more

Loading results ...

Share this post:

You might also like